I concur with what abigail and rowan have brought up, but I also like a lot of the ideas being floated from chillsubs hq. I would personally like for potentially scammy mags or presses to be able to get flagged in a way that is distinctive from "this magazine took 2 months longer than they said they would to get to my submission." The second kind of information is still valuable but is different from the first. I like the idea of positive badges and I definitely think it's good that in order to leave a negative badge, you have to leave a comment explaining why, and these would be moderated. I'm sure there will inevitably be a bit of trial and error with this process though, which is totally fine!